« Vases: A passion for blue and white | Main | Fiber Friday: Licorice »

Thursday, February 13, 2014

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Erin @ The Impatient Gardener

I couldn't agree more, Linda. I'm not a huge Elizabeth Gilbert fan, but it was the botany aspect of the book that led me to pick it up. By three-quarters of the way through I was thoroughly annoyed with it but felt like I had invested so much time into it already I owed it to myself to see it through to the end. I thought the whole thing was a rather self-indulgent exercise by Gilbert.

I'm a bit relieved to read that you were similarly disappointed in the book. I was thinking maybe there was something I missed with all the hubbub about it.

LINDA from EACH LITTLE WORLD

Erin — ​So glad to know I am not alone.

I felt the same way, that I'd gone too far to abandon it. I kept thinking she would somehow redeem the story. Duh!

Janet Maslin in the NYTimes gave it a pretty good review and had it in her best list at the end of the year which is what spurred me on.

I am swearing off on best selling popular books!​

Lisa — ​I think you and I and Erin got hooked in because we are gardeners. I find it fascinating that we all had the same response . . .

Lisa at Greenbow

I also read this book and ended up wondering why I finished it. Not a satisfying read except for a few tidbits as you mention.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Contact

  • E-mail: lbrazill@gmail.com

Words & Images

  • The copyright to photos on this Web site is held by the photographer, Mark Golbach, unless credited otherwise. Original text is copyright by Linda Brazill. Please contact for permission to use.